Are you ready to learn about a killer Netflix documentary series that will give you the chills of True Crime podcasts? Well, the show we are going to talk about is called American Nightmare (2024) Season 2, and it is going to give you chills.
It is so close to reality that it can happen to anyone. As some fans say, the American Nightmare docu-series is āGone Girl gone real!ā Do you want to know more about this awesome show?
[adinserter block=9]
We say you stick around till the end to know if this show can be your next favourite show. In this article, we will talk about American Nightmare (2024) Season 2, the plot of the series, the production status, the expected plot of American Nightmare, ratings, where to watch this show, and so much more. So letās get started!
American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 Key Highlights
- American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 doesn’t have a confirmed release date, but based on previous patterns, it may be anticipated in the coming year 2024.
- With an IMDb score of 7.9 out of 10, American Nightmare is gaining popularity as a hidden gem for True Crime Drama enthusiasts.
- Exclusively available on Netflix, American Nightmare offers a captivating exploration of real-life crime cases.
[adinserter block=13]
American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 Overview
Title: | American Nightmare |
No. of Seasons: | 1 |
No. of Episodes: | 3 |
Produced by: | Felicity Morris and Bernadette Higgins |
Genre: | True Crime, Docuseries |
Cast: | Denise Huskins, Aaron Quinn |
Language: | English |
First Episode Date: | January 18, 2024 |
Last Episode Date: | January 18, 2024 |
Available On: | Netflix |
Also Read
Arak Season 2 Release Date, Star Cast, Story, & Everything We Know So Far
Chicago Med Season 9 Release Date, Spoiler, Episode Guide, Trailer & Where to watch
[adinserter block=1]
When Is American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 Coming Out? (Release Date)
American Nightmare Season 1 is out! Yes, the three-part season 1 was released on January 17, 2024. So, after watching Season 1, you must be wondering, āWhen is American Nightmare (2024) Season 2?ā because you just want to be left hanging. You want the complete story!
Well, sorry folks, we hate to break it to you that this was a mini-series. It was supposed to be just a three-part documentary series.
However, the makers Felicity Morris and Bernadette Higgins wonāt be stopping just from Tinder Swindlers to American Nightmare; there is no stopping this documentary-directing duo.
We are sure to see yet another similar crime-based documentary series from them, probably next year.
What is The Production Status of American Nightmare (2024) Season 2
As for the production status of American Nightmare Season 2. Directors Felicity Morris and Bernadette Higgins have yet to give us any news on that. They love to work together and have produced many such amazing Netflix docu-series.
As of now, there are rumours and talks about the duo collaborating on a new project however the project remains unnamed and we are not sure if it is American Nightmare (2024) Season 2. Letās hope to get some news by the end of 2024.
[adinserter block=8]
American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 Storyline: What Would It Be Able to Be About?
The plot of American Nightmare is twisted, but a simpler version of it would be that it is a kidnapping case that left the cops confused and frustrated. This story revolves around a couple, where the girlfriend is Denise Huskins and the boyfriend is Aaron Quinn.

They were living quite a content life when one night their house got invaded. The home invaders kidnapped Huskins, and she went missing for the longest period of time. Her boyfriend was the prime suspect, and all the interrogation videos have been shown in this documentary series.
It all seems quite a straight case that is of a kidnapping; however, it becomes puzzling when Denise gets dropped off by a car and, without a hint of trauma, gets inside her house.
This shocks the police, as no person who ever gets kidnapped is dropped in front of their house, and that too without a scratch or trauma. This made the police suspect the couple, and people called Aaron and Denise hoaxers, which brought them much shame.
However, four years after the incident, a man named Mathew Muller was linked to Deniseās kidnapping case, and it turns out she was telling the truth all along! She was kidnapped and sexually assaulted, but the cops judged her based on her lack of physical trauma and called her a hoaxer instead of getting her justice.
This show goes deeper into the details of the case, and we are sure you will love the truth behind the “real-life Gone Girlā story.
[adinserter block=3]
What Happened at the End of American Nightmare (2024) Season 1?
The ending brings some sweet, sweet justice for Denice and Aaron, and the cops finally realize their mistake. Like in the plot, Aaron was the prime suspect, and the return of Denise did not make the case look good.
The police chalked it up to the couple being a hoax and the kidnapping being fake, despite Deniseās constant pleading for help.
She did report that she was kidnapped, drugged, and sexually assaulted, but then she was safely dropped, which was mysterious on the part of the kidnapper, and it wasnāt her fault, but the police simply denied hearing her out.
When, after 4 years, Matthew Muller was arrested for sexual assault, cop Misty Carausu tracked his links all the way to Denise. That is it. It was proven that Denise was, in fact, telling the truth!
[adinserter block=13]
Vallejo police had to say sorry to the couple, and the couple, Aaron and Denise, filed a defamation lawsuit, which they settled for $2.5 million. As for Muller? Well, he got 40 years in prison.
The docuseries ends with Carausu lauding Carausu for going into the depths of Mullerās case and bringing out the truth, while the Vallejo police were criticized for their incompetent investigation methods.
What Can We Expect from American Nightmare (2024) Season 2?
Well as mentioned before American Nightmare was a mini docu-series and it is supposed to only have three parts. We came to a conclusion of the Huskin Kidnapping case in Season 1 itself.
Expecting a American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 can either bring in a new case regarding yet another horrific home invasion case, a kidnapping case or yet another confusing case.
However, we do not expect to see Aaron and Denise to be back for American Nightmare Season 2, because their nightmare ended the day Denise got justice. We might get to see more of Misty Carausu in the next season if there is one.
[adinserter block=6]
Also Read
Who Will Be Part of American Nightmare (2024) Season 2? (Cast and Character)

Cast | Character |
Denise Huskins | Self |
Aaron Quinn | Self |
Henry Lee | Self – San Francisco Chronicle |
Amy Morton | Self – Defense Attorney |
Mike Huskins | Self – Denise’s Father |
Kenny Park | Self – Lieutenant Vallejo PD |
Marianne Quinn | Self – Aaron’s Mother |
[adinserter block=4]
How Is the Season Rated So Far?
On IMDb, American Nightmare has scored 7.9 out of 10. As the show is extremely new the ratings may fluctuate every day now. The show is slowly gaining popularity while on Rotten Tomatoes, there are no ratings available.
However, according to the reviews, it is clear that this show is the definition of a hidden gem that needs to be discovered by the right audience. By right audience we mean the people who live for True Crime Dramas. This is for you to go ahead and watch it! As one review said and we quote āThis is Real Life Gone Girl but way more twisted.ā
[adinserter block=5]
Shows Like American Nightmare (2024) Season 2
How Many Episodes of American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 Will Be There?
American Nightmare (2024) Season 2 will probably be yet another mini Docu-series with 3 to 4 episodes, each episode running for 60 minutes to 90 minutes. Each episode will consist of recordings of the interrogations, the policeās point of view, and the victimās interview on their traumatic story.
If American Nightmare directors comes up with an American Nightmare Season 2, it will be quite difficult to beat the craze of Season 1, because Season 1 was a masterpiece!
[adinserter block=7]
Where Can You Watch The Show?
The only place to watch this amazing crime documentary is Netflix. Unfortunately, you need to pay for a subscription as there are no free trial offers available.
But on the bright side, you can cancel anytime! Also, it is best to use a legal platform to watch any show because this gives you a good watching experience and saves you a lot of hassle.
Is There Any News āAmerican Nightmare (2024) Season 2ā Trailer?
While a trailer for American Nightmare Season 2 is not currently available, the trailer for the previous season provided a glimpse into the intense storytelling and gripping real-life crime narratives. Viewers can anticipate another thrilling installment as the directors continue their exploration of compelling cases.
[adinserter block=10]
FAQS about American Nightmare (2024) Season 2
[adinserter block=11]
No, American Nightmare Season 2 has not been released; Season 1, a three-part documentary series, was completed.
The plot for Season 2 remains uncertain, as Season 1 concluded the Denise Huskins kidnapping case. Future seasons may explore new crime cases.
American Nightmare is exclusively available on Netflix; a subscription is required to access the crime documentary.
The episode count for Season 2 is unknown, but based on the format of the mini-series, it may have 3 to 4 episodes.
Felicity Morris and Bernadette Higgins are the directors of the American Nightmare documentary series.
[adinserter block=12]
[adinserter block=13]